Hakamaya Noriaki and Matsumoto Shirõ are convinced that
tathāgatagarbha theory and the Yogācāra school share a common framework that they call
dhātu-vāda or "locus theory." The word
dhātu-vāda itself is a neologism introduced by Matsumoto'"`UNIQ--ref-00000002-QINU`"' and adopted by Hakamaya.'"`UNIQ--ref-00000003-QINU`"' They argue that the
dhātu-vāda idea stands in direct contradiction to the authentic Buddhist theory of
pratītyasamutpāda or "dependent origination," which in turn leads them to consider
tathāgata-garbha and Yogācāra theories to be non-Buddhist. In their opinion, not only these Indian theories but also the whole of "original enlightenment thought" (
hongaku shisõ) in East Asia fell under the shadow of the
dhātu-vāda idea,'"`UNIQ--ref-00000004-QINU`"' with the result that most of its Buddhism is dismissed as not Buddhist at all.'"`UNIQ--ref-00000005-QINU`"'
The idea of
dhātu-vāda is thus an integral part of the Critical Buddhism critique and as such merits careful examination in any evaluation of the overall standpoint. Since Matsumoto first found the
dhātu-vāda structure in Indian
tathāgata-garbha and Yogācāra literature, we need to begin with a look at the texts in question. My approach here will be purely philological and will limit itself to the theoretical treatises (śāstras). (Yamabe, introductory remarks, 193)
Read more here:
Yamabe, Nobuyoshi. "The Idea of Dhātu-vāda in Yogācāra and Tathāgata-garbha Texts." In Pruning the Bodhi Tree: The Storm over Critical Buddhism, edited by Jamie Hubbard and Paul L. Swanson, 193–204. Honolulu: University of Hawai’i Press, 1997.
Yamabe, Nobuyoshi. "The Idea of Dhātu-vāda in Yogācāra and Tathāgata-garbha Texts." In Pruning the Bodhi Tree: The Storm over Critical Buddhism, edited by Jamie Hubbard and Paul L. Swanson, 193–204. Honolulu: University of Hawai’i Press, 1997.;The Idea of Dhātu-vāda in Yogācāra and Tathāgata-garbha Texts;Critical Buddhism;tathāgatagarbha;Yogācāra;pratītyasamutpāda;Original Enlightenment;Matsumoto, S.;Hakamaya, N.;Nobuyoshi Yamabe;